...

Have you ever looked at a neighbor’s roof and noticed strange patterns in the shingles?

Maybe one section looks darker than another. Perhaps you can see noticeable patches or repeating patterns across the roof.

These roof shingle color variations can stand out even more when the roof is relatively new.

We recently shared a video showing exactly what we’re talking about.

The shingles appear to have noticeably different shades throughout the roof. Instead of a natural, blended appearance, certain sections stand out from the others.

So why does this happen?

More importantly, how can homeowners avoid spending thousands of dollars on a new roof only to end up with noticeable color patterns?

This is one of the reasons we prefer installing CertainTeed shingles at Level Up Improvement.

Why Do Some Roofs Have Noticeable Shingle Color Patterns?

Most architectural asphalt shingles contain a mixture of colored granules.

Manufacturers combine these granules to create the finished color of the shingle.

For example, a charcoal-colored roof isn’t necessarily made from shingles containing only one shade of black.

The shingles may contain several shades of black, gray, and other complementary colors.

These variations create the dimensional appearance homeowners expect from architectural shingles.

However, problems can arise when the overall color blend looks noticeably different between groups of shingles.

Instead of creating a natural appearance, the roof develops patches or patterns that draw your attention.

Sometimes the differences are subtle.

Other times, you can spot them from across the street.

What Are Shingle Dye Lots, and Why Do They Matter?

You may have heard the term dye lot when purchasing carpet, flooring, tile, or other building materials.

The idea is fairly simple.

Manufacturers produce materials in different batches. Slight differences in color can sometimes occur between those batches.

Roofing shingles have a similar concern, although manufacturers use colored mineral granules rather than simply dyeing the finished shingles.

If the color blends vary noticeably between production runs, homeowners may see differences after installation.

Imagine purchasing a new roof in a dark gray color.

You expect the entire roof to have a consistent appearance with natural variations throughout.

Instead, one section looks noticeably darker than the section next to it.

Even if the shingles are performing properly, that appearance can be disappointing.

After all, a new roof should improve your home’s curb appeal, not create a pattern that catches your eye for the wrong reasons.

Why Some Shingle Manufacturers Recommend Mixing Bundles

Here’s something many homeowners probably don’t know.

Some roofing manufacturers recommend mixing shingles from multiple bundles during installation.

The idea is to distribute any color differences across the roof instead of concentrating them in one area.

For example, rather than installing an entire bundle and then opening the next one, the installer alternates shingles from different packages.

This can help blend variations and reduce noticeable patches.

In theory, it makes sense.

But let’s talk about what actually happens on a roof.

Roofers Are Working Hard All Day Long

Roof replacement is physically demanding work.

Crews spend hours carrying materials, removing old shingles, installing underlayment, and working on steep roof slopes.

During a busy installation, they’re trying to maintain a steady pace while following proper installation procedures.

Now imagine asking those installers to continually open multiple bundles and alternate shingles throughout the day.

Is it possible? Absolutely.

Should they follow that procedure when the manufacturer requires it? Of course.

But is it realistic to assume every installer will carefully mix shingles from several packages throughout an entire roof replacement?

We wouldn’t count on that happening every single time.

And that’s the problem.

We believe manufacturers should do everything possible to produce consistent shingle colors before the bundles ever reach the jobsite.

A homeowner shouldn’t have to rely entirely on an installer manually blending different packages to achieve an attractive finished roof.

Why Level Up Improvement Prefers CertainTeed Shingles

At Level Up Improvement, we frequently install CertainTeed Landmark PRO shingles throughout Southeast Michigan.

There are several reasons we like the product, including its construction, appearance, and warranty protection.

But color consistency is another important consideration.

CertainTeed uses carefully developed granule blends and controlled manufacturing processes to produce its shingle colors.

The company explains that its Max Def colors use specific combinations of granules to create the dimensional appearance of its Landmark PRO shingles.

These colors are designed to provide a rich, natural-looking blend across the finished roof.

That matters because we want homeowners to see an attractive, cohesive roof when our installation is complete.

We don’t want obvious patches of color distracting from the rest of the house.

Natural Color Variation Is a Good Thing

There’s an important distinction between natural color variation and unwanted color differences.

Architectural shingles are supposed to have different shades.

That’s what creates depth and dimension.

CertainTeed Landmark PRO shingles use multiple granule colors to achieve that appearance.

For example, Moire Black contains variations that create a dimensional black roof rather than a completely flat color.

The goal isn’t to make every shingle look identical.

The goal is to make the variations work together so the roof looks consistent as a whole.

That is the appearance we want for our customers.

You can explore the available colors on the CertainTeed Landmark PRO product page.

What Happens if a CertainTeed Roof Has a Manufacturing Color Defect?

This is where CertainTeed offers another important advantage.

No manufacturer can realistically guarantee that every product will be perfect every single time.

Manufacturing problems are rare, but they can happen.

What matters is how the manufacturer responds.

CertainTeed states that its shingle warranties cover qualifying manufacturing defects, including defects that affect appearance without causing leaks.

That’s a significant distinction.

Some roofing warranties focus primarily on defects that affect the performance of the shingles.

CertainTeed also recognizes that homeowners care about how their roofs look.

Why Cosmetic Warranty Coverage Matters

Imagine installing a brand-new roof.

The shingles don’t leak. They aren’t blowing off. Everything appears to function properly.

But there’s a noticeable manufacturing-related color defect across part of the roof.

You didn’t spend thousands of dollars expecting that appearance.

CertainTeed’s warranty protection against qualifying aesthetic manufacturing defects gives homeowners an additional layer of reassurance.

Of course, the manufacturer must determine that the issue qualifies as a manufacturing defect.

Normal color variation, installation errors, and other excluded conditions don’t automatically qualify for coverage.

The specific remedy also depends on the product warranty and its terms.

Still, we think this protection is worth considering when comparing roofing manufacturers.

You can read more in CertainTeed’s explanation of roofing warranties.

What Is CertainTeed SureStart Protection?

CertainTeed includes SureStart protection with its asphalt roofing shingles.

This provides enhanced coverage during the early years of the manufacturer’s limited warranty.

For qualifying manufacturing defects during the applicable SureStart period, coverage can include replacement materials and labor.

The exact coverage depends on the shingle product and warranty terms.

That’s important because correcting a manufacturing problem may involve much more than replacing a few individual shingles.

A homeowner could face significant labor costs if a substantial section of the roof requires replacement.

CertainTeed’s warranty is one reason we feel comfortable recommending its products.

We’re not just looking at how a roof looks on installation day.

We’re also considering what happens if a manufacturing issue appears later.

Does This Mean CertainTeed Shingles Never Have Color Variations?

No, and we wouldn’t tell homeowners that.

All architectural shingles have intentional color variations.

Lighting, roof slope, viewing angle, and the natural granule blend can also affect their appearance.

Even high-quality manufacturers can occasionally experience production issues.

What we like about CertainTeed is its attention to color design, manufacturing quality, and warranty protection.

We want to minimize the chance of noticeable color inconsistencies.

And in the unlikely event of a qualifying manufacturing defect, we want our customers to have meaningful manufacturer support.

That’s a much better conversation than telling someone their new roof looks patchy because the crew didn’t mix enough bundles.

What Should You Ask Your Roofing Contractor About Shingle Colors?

Most homeowners spend plenty of time choosing a roof color.

They look at samples, compare pictures, and try to imagine how the finished roof will complement their siding and trim.

But very few ask about color consistency between bundles.

We think that’s worth discussing.

Before choosing a roofing product, ask your contractor:

  1. Does the manufacturer recommend mixing shingles from different bundles?
  2. How does the manufacturer control color consistency?
  3. What happens if noticeable color differences appear after installation?
  4. Does the manufacturer cover qualifying cosmetic defects?
  5. Who handles a warranty claim if there’s a problem?

These are reasonable questions.

A good roofing contractor should explain the answers before installation begins.

Why We Install CertainTeed Landmark PRO in Southeast Michigan

Michigan roofs deal with a lot.

Between heavy snow, strong winds, summer heat, and freezing temperatures, homeowners need shingles that can handle changing weather.

But performance isn’t the only consideration.

Appearance matters too.

A roof covers a large portion of your home’s visible exterior. Its color and overall appearance can make a major difference in curb appeal.

That’s one reason we frequently recommend CertainTeed Landmark PRO.

The product offers a dimensional architectural appearance, a broad selection of colors, and manufacturer warranty protection.

We’ve installed Landmark PRO shingles in colors such as Moire Black, Espresso, and Cobblestone Gray on homes throughout Metro Detroit.

Our customers expect their new roofs to look good.

We think they should also feel confident about the products going on their homes.

Frequently Asked Questions About Roof Shingle Color Variations

Why does my new roof have different-colored shingles?

Roof shingle color variations may result from intentional granule blends, manufacturing differences, lighting, or installation practices.

A roofing contractor can evaluate whether the appearance is normal for the product.

Do roofers need to mix shingles from different bundles?

Some manufacturers recommend blending shingles from multiple bundles to distribute color variations.

Contractors should always follow the installation instructions for the specific product.

Do CertainTeed shingles have color variations?

Yes. CertainTeed architectural shingles contain intentional color variations that create their dimensional appearance.

The company uses controlled granule blends to achieve its intended colors.

Does CertainTeed cover shingle color defects?

CertainTeed states that its warranties cover qualifying manufacturing defects, including certain defects affecting appearance.

However, not every color difference qualifies as a defect. The manufacturer evaluates claims according to the applicable warranty.

Are CertainTeed Landmark PRO shingles worth the money?

For homeowners who value dimensional appearance, product construction, color selection, and manufacturer warranty protection, Landmark PRO is worth considering.

The best choice still depends on your budget, roof design, and priorities.

Watch Our Video: Have You Ever Noticed These Patterns on a Roof?

We recently shared a video showing noticeable color patterns across an asphalt shingle roof.

It’s a great example of something homeowners might overlook when comparing roofing estimates.

Most people focus on the brand, color, and price.

But color consistency and manufacturer warranty coverage deserve attention too.

Watch the video here:

Why We Believe the Manufacturer Matters Just as Much as the Installer

A good roofing crew is important.

But so are the materials they’re installing.

We don’t believe homeowners should have to choose between quality workmanship and quality products.

They deserve both.

At Level Up Improvement, we’re a family-owned roofing and exterior remodeling company serving Southeast Michigan.

We believe in explaining the products we recommend and giving homeowners honest advice.

That’s why we like CertainTeed.

Its Landmark PRO shingles offer the appearance we’re looking for, while the manufacturer’s warranty provides additional reassurance.

No roofing manufacturer is perfect.

But when we’re putting a new roof on someone’s home, we want to use products we trust.

For examples of our work, check out our Bloomfield Hills roof replacement featuring CertainTeed Landmark PRO shingles.

You can also see our Bloomfield Hills exterior transformation or learn more about Level Up Improvement.

Considering a New Roof in Southeast Michigan?

If you’re planning a roof replacement, we’d be happy to explain the differences between roofing products and help you choose the right option.

Level Up Improvement serves Royal Oak, Rochester Hills, Troy, Birmingham, Bloomfield Hills, Novi, Ferndale, Clawson, Waterford, Dearborn, and surrounding Metro Detroit communities.

Call (313) 287-9525 or visit levelupimprovement.com to request an estimate.

No three-hour sales presentation. No high-pressure tactics.

Just honest advice, quality materials, and workmanship we stand behind.

Level Up Improvement. Do it right!