Getting a Roof or Siding Estimate? How to Set Yourself (and Your Contractor) Up for Success
If you’re thinking about replacing your roof or siding — or you’re actively gathering estimates — there’s one thing that can make the entire process smoother, more accurate, and far less stressful: preparation.
This isn’t about picking a specific brand or material. It’s about understanding how estimates work and how homeowners can help contractors give their best, most accurate advice and pricing. Good projects start with good communication, and that goes both ways.
Here’s what every homeowner should know before scheduling a roof or siding estimate, this can help with pretty much any type of estimate on your house.
Be Ready to Talk About the Project
One of the biggest misconceptions about estimates is that contractors should “just know” what you need by looking at your house. In reality, the more information you can share, the better the outcome will be.
Be prepared to answer questions like:
-
What are you hoping to accomplish with this project?
-
Are you looking for a full replacement or a repair?
-
Are there specific issues you’ve noticed (leaks, drafts, loose siding, ice dams)?
-
What’s your general timeline?
There are no wrong answers here. Even if you’re unsure, saying “I don’t know, I’m looking for guidance” is completely fair — and helpful.
Know the History of Your Home (As Best You Can)
Contractors aren’t asking questions to trip you up or find a “gotcha.” They’re gathering context.
Helpful details include:
-
How old is the house?
-
When was the roof last replaced?
-
When was the siding installed?
-
Have windows, doors, kitchens, or additions been updated?
-
Has any work already been done in the area being quoted?
Even rough estimates like “early 2000s” or “before we bought the house” are useful. Past work affects how new work is installed, tied in, and warranted.
Give the Contractor Time to Do It Right
A good estimate isn’t rushed.
Accurate pricing often requires:
-
Measuring multiple areas
-
Inspecting details
-
Reviewing ventilation and drainage
-
Accounting for code requirements
-
Pricing materials correctly
If a contractor takes their time, that’s usually a green flag, not a red one. You’re not just paying for labor — you’re paying for planning, experience, and risk management.
This is not to say that a contractor needs 3+ hours to deliver a sales presentation, someone who is really an expert can and will provide you with the correct information in a timely manner – they just might need some time to determine the best course of action.
Let Them Inside (Yes, Really)
If it’s a roof estimate, a contractor should want to look inside your home — especially in the attic.
This isn’t about searching for problems to scare you into a bigger job. Think of it like an X-ray for your roof.
An attic inspection can reveal:
-
Ventilation issues
-
Moisture or condensation
-
Insulation levels
-
Signs of past leaks
-
Structural concerns
Without this information, an estimate is incomplete — and incomplete estimates often lead to surprises later.
Also, on a human level: if it’s cold out, please allow contractors to come inside. A warm, respectful environment goes a long way toward a better interaction and better service.
A Small Thing That Matters More Than You’d Think: Pets
Before someone walks your property, please pick up after your pets.
It sounds obvious, but it’s overlooked more often than you’d expect. Contractors are measuring, walking your yard, setting ladders, and moving quickly. A clean yard isn’t just courteous — it’s safer for everyone.
Understanding Pricing (And Contractor Reputations)
Contractors often get a bad reputation, and while there are bad actors out there, pricing alone doesn’t tell the whole story.
Some companies:
-
Are extremely expensive and still deliver poor workmanship
-
Are very cheap and do excellent installs — but struggle with communication or scheduling
A high price does not guarantee quality.
A low price does not automatically mean bad work.
Pricing reflects many things: overhead, insurance, crews, systems, experience, and service. It’s important to look beyond the number and understand how and why a company operates the way it does and a great contractor should be transparent with you about these things.
Communication Is One of the Biggest Green Flags
One of the best indicators of a good contractor is how they communicate before you hire them.
Look for companies that:
-
Answer calls or return them promptly
-
Are happy to explain things
-
Encourage questions
-
Offer advice without pressure
-
Respect your pace and decision-making
If a company communicates well when you’re not yet a customer, there’s a strong chance that behavior continues after the contract is signed.
Ask About Crews and Installation Practices
This is an area many homeowners overlook — and it matters.
Most contractors use subcontractors. That alone is not a red flag.
What does matter is:
-
Do they use the same crews consistently?
-
Are the crews experienced with that company’s standards?
-
Or are they constantly rotating through the cheapest available labor?
Consistency leads to predictable results. Contractors who work with the same crews over and over again usually have better quality control.
Be cautious of companies that feel more like sales organizations than construction companies:
-
High-pressure, “sign today” tactics
-
Claims of “all in-house installers” without transparency
-
Reluctance to explain how jobs are actually installed
Using subcontractors is normal. Lying about it is not.
Trust Your Gut — and Communicate Both Ways
At the end of the day, trust matters.
You should feel comfortable:
-
Asking questions
-
Saying you need time
-
Admitting what you don’t know
-
Expecting honest answers
Most contractors are good people who take pride in their work and want to do right by their customers. Clear communication, mutual respect, and realistic expectations make the process better for everyone involved.
A successful project starts long before the first shingle or piece of siding is installed — it starts with a good conversation.
Please be sure to check out our ever growing blog!